Our Pie Menu

This pie is a traditional "PA German-Dutch" recipe from my great-grandma. It's a rich molasses-style "cake" nestled in a wet molasses bottom in a buttery flaky crust, and then topped with a flavorful crumb topping. This pie doesn't need to be refrigerated and is great for breakfast as well. If you've never had one, we promise you'll come back for another!

Fresh made lemon curd, meringue topping and flaky pie crust

Fresh made key lime curd, whipped cream topping and buttery graham cracker crust

Fort Mill Bakery is the place to come for delicious cream pies. Our pies are available in 9-inch diameter with a traditional topping and graham crust. Some pies like our custard, egg, and sugar pies don’t have a whipped cream topping. However, whipped cream topping is available upon request. Our cream pies variety is:

• Sugar Cream (AKA Hoosier Pie) 
• Chocolate (pictured)
• Chocolate Peanut Butter (AKA Buckeye Pie) 
• Coconut
• Caramel Macchiato
• Banana
• Peanut Butter Dream
• Egg Custard. 

Fort Mill Bakery is aware of the rising cost of all things. So, we still want to bring joy and smiles by means of our half pie.

You order the pie flavor - fruit or cream and simply state that its half the pie. You won't receive a pie that looks like the image above, but a whole pie that serves 4. So a mini pie of the full version that's great for an afternoon tea or just meeting a friend. 

NOTE: THE SHOO_FLY PIE IS the only pie not available as a half pie. 

We kindly ask you to please complete our online order form first.  If we have any questions or concerns regarding the order or payment, we will reach out to you within the next 24 to 48 hours. All orders will receive a confirmation email or text message. (Please note that both email and phone are required on the order form.)

If an order is processed without online payment, you will receive an invoice within the next 24 to 48 hours. Full payment is required on all orders prior to our fulfillment.

Our mission is to provide you with high-quality, freshly made custom products. We pride ourselves on the quality of our products, not the quantity, and our reputation and client reviews speak for themselves. If you fail to plan ahead, we cannot rush any pie order, so please order your pie at least five days in advance of your expected date.

 Our 9" Apple Pie uses a variety of apples used to create this mouth-watering pie with our handmade flaky bottom crust. Choose either a lattice top or Crumb Top when ordering. 

This is Just like the one grandma use to make!   This is our most requested pie so we left it have its rightful place on our menu!

All pies have a flaky buttery crust. When using the online order form, please let us know if you prefer a crumb crust top, lattice top or a full crust top on your pie. If you fail to tell us, we will place a lattice top on every fruit pie. Thank you. 

Our fruit pie selection is:

• Blueberry
• Blackberry
• Strawberry Rhubarb (in season)
• Maple Bourbon Peach 
• Peach 
• Strawberry (not baked-no gelatin is used though in our recipe) 
• Baked Strawberry Pie (automatically has crumb topping) 

 Fresh local pumpkins are used to create this smooth and rich crème pie with a flaky bottom crust. 

Fall - Winter Seasonal Item

Our mission is to provide you with high-quality, freshly made custom products. We pride ourselves on the quality of our products, not the quantity, and our reputation and client reviews speak for themselves. If you fail to plan ahead, we cannot rush any cheesecake order, so please order your cheesecake at least 3-5 days in advance of your expected date. We request this due to scheduling time in our shared commercial kitchen space and proud of our 100% Grade A rating from SCDEH. 

 Fort Mill Bakery offer a Traditional NY Style 9 inch Cheesecake that is baked on our own graham cracker crust. The cheesecake is smooth and silky and is sure to melt in your mouth. This cheesecake is made fresh to order so please allow 5 days for pre-order. This is a delicious cheesecake that you are sure to love!

Fort Mill Bakery's Cheesecakes have crusts made of graham crackers, except for their chocolate and/or marbled cheesecakes, which have chocolate crumb crusts. They come in flavors like blueberry, blackberry, peach, raspberry, strawberry, chocolate, caramel, and pumpkin. When you order online, you can choose which flavor of cheesecake you'd like. 

Our Cheesecake selection is:

• Blueberry
• Blackberry
• Peach  
• Raspberry
• Strawberry 
• Mango & Passionfruit (pictured)
• Pumpkin (in season- fall winter)

 Indulge yourself to the ultimate cheesecake experience for any of our cheesecakes, but in half.  So we create you half a cheesecake from our choices listed in our menu here. You just need to tell us which one you'd like.

Our cheesecake half won't look like the one above, but a whole cheesecake offering the same servings as a half would - which is 4-6 depending upon the portion sliced. 

 Indulge yourself to the ultimate cheesecake experience. Our Marbled Cheesecakes fuse rich flavors with visually stunning swirls. They're a cheesecake lover's dream. When completing your online order form, make sure to tell us which marbled cheesecake flavor you're ordering. Choose from the following:

• Mocha 
• Strawberry
• Raspberry (pictured)
• Traditional (plain & chocolate) 
• White Chocolate & Caramel

 Indulge in the ultimate chocolate cheesecake experience. Our Chocolate Cheesecakes fuse rich Belgian Chocolate flavors with our chocolate crumb crusts and come in several flavors. Be sure to tell us your favorite when using the online order form. Choose from the following:

• Traditional Chocolate (pictured in mini size for the photo - sorry we
• Bittersweet
• Mint
• Caramel Fudge
• Chocolate Peanut Butter 
• Just Peanut Butter (no chocolate)
• Almond
• Smores
• Oreo
• Raspberry
• Blackberry