Our Custom Cake Menu

This is a specialty cake we offer as a thr-layer five-inch cake that is cake is fully decorated in an elegant design. It is the perfect size for a small party or gathering. It’s better than our competition but priced to meet what you’d expect from local grocery stores. If you need a message on the cake let us know in the order form. We also offer this cake as a porch pick

Cake flavors are listed under 6" cake.

• Serves 8
• Fillings are $5 + cake 
• order here 
• 3 day advance notice for simple designs. 

Cakes are custom order & all layer cakes have a buttercream frosting. This cake serves 12-15

Standard cake flavors are: 

• Vanilla
• Almond
• Chocolate
• Marble Cake 
• Tiramisu
• Snickerdoodle Cake 
• Caramel
• Strawberry 
• Shortcake-strawberry
• Lemon Layer Cake 
• Margarita Lime 
• Coconut Layer
• Fall spice
• Gingerbread 
• Red Velvet (pictured) 
• Cheesecake (Natural flavor) 
• Banana Fosters Layer Cake 
• Carrot Cake 
• flavor not listed, simply ask & we'll make it 
• require 3 day minimal notice for simple designs (Happy Birth

Our bakery can complete simple cake designs on short notice, typically within three business days. For more intricate designs, including edible art details, we require at least two week's notice.

Online Order & Payment Procedures:

Please complete the order form in its entirety to ensure that we can fulfill your order according to your expectations and send you an invoice in a timely manner. Any omissions or errors in the information you provide will delay the processing of your order.

Fort Mill Bakery will deliver a sweet treat to help you get through even the rough patches. But we must address the ever-increasing price of eggs, which is an ingredient in most of our bakery products.We're committed to maintaining the affordability of our services, but the cost of eggs has steadily climbed, even threatening the existence of our bakery. We're doing what we can to absorb the cost; some items may receive a surcharge in addition to the price listed, simply bc it uses more eggs. 

Cakes are custom order cakes & all have a buttercream frosting. 

8" cake flavors are the same as for the 6" cake flavors. 

• Fillings are extra @ $5 + cake price 
• serves up to 24
• require 7 day advance notice for cake like pictured above, simpler designs 3 day Minimum advance notice. 
• standard HBD cake size
• order here

All cakes are frosted with buttercream. If you would like to enhance your cake with a filling, please select from our selection below, & add your choice to the order form. We will send you an email or text if we have a concern about your request

1. Dark Chocolate Ganache

2. Milk Chocolate Ganache

3. Strawberry Compote

4. Blueberry Compote

5. Pineapple compote (pairs with Vanilla, Coconut or Margarita cakes.)

6. Caramel

*Note: Our fillings pair well with all our cake flavors, but we are open to

I am thankful to have a second year in a row where I get a 100% Grade A rating as a bakery owner and pastry chef.  I know that I am required to use a commercial kitchen for the desserts I present to you in my menu.  Fortunately, I am able to work out of one in York SC. & this opportunity provides my clients & neighbors with tasty desserts! This is a privilege I enjoy & do not take for granted. Having this is the chance of a lifetime to create desserts that I've always liked creating.

Fort Mill Bakery does offer cupcakes for as smaller sweet to the main item for your special occasion, or as an addition to your dessert table for a larger event. All cupcakes are sold by the dozen

Please specify flavor of cake/cupcakes in your order (limit of 2 flavors for cupcakes)   You can substitute cookies or macarons for pretzels in the order. 

Rush orders for cupcakes incur an extra rush fee.  A week notice prior to the date expected is appreciated for larger events.

3D Custom Cakes & Design Cakes

•  Our 3D design cakes are created for your event or can be requested. If you can think of it, we can create it, and it's all edible! Our custom design cakes have been created for weddings, anniversaries, birthdays, and baby showers. 

Sheet Cakes

• Quarter, Half & Full size available

*We request a 2 weeks notice & your servings needed/order. We bake love and care into every order. Please contact us for pricing by email. Please see our event page for Tiered/Wedding Cakes.