Fort Mill Bakery's Fall Seasonal Menu

Fall Seasonal Menu Items

Rustic cake decorated with greenery and doughnuts on a wooden slice.

Fall menu

Fall Seasonal Menu ~ Thanksgiving menu items are available thru November 22

Our fall seasonal menu features a variety of sweet and savory treats, all made from scratch with the finest ingredients. From our signature pumpkin roll to our pies and apple dumplings, there is something for everyone at Fort Mill Bakery. Browse our menu and place your order today!
Those who place an order in October for Thanksgiving can donate a pie (or the cost of one) to Hurricane victims.

A round cake decorated with chocolate and vanilla frosting swirls and colorful sprinkles.

Fall Inspired Cakes

start at $50

We offer our cakes in a 5" or 8" layer cake. You can choose from the following Fall flavors:

Red Velvet
Snickerdoodle
German Chocolate
Cannoli
Tiramisu
Fall Spice
Gingerbread
Black Forest
Butterscotch

Simply place the cake flavor and size in the order form and when you expect the order and its that simple! All frosting is buttercream and we chose the flavor that best compliments the cake. Question or request... Ask us on the order form or give us a call!

Glazed mini bundt cakes garnished with cherries and orange peels.

Fall Bundt Cakes

$75

We offer traditionally created Bundt Cakes with a touch of fall flavors like:

Chocolate Stoudt
Pumpkin Chip
Apple Spice
Root beer Bundt Cake with Dark Chocolate Root beer Glaze (this is our family favorite!)
Lemon Basic Bundt Cake with Cinnamon Glaze
Vanilla Bourbon Pumpkin Banana Bundt

Simply place the cake flavor, when you expect the order in the order form & its that simple!

A slice of cheesecake being served from a whole cheesecake.

Fall Cheesecakes

$55

Love cheesecake? We do too! All cheesecake flavors were inspired by local coffee shops or simply what we thought of combining into a cheesecake! All cheesecakes are 9" and serve about 16. You can choose the following:

Caramel Macchiato
Vanilla Bourbon Spice
Double Layer Pumpkin
Cheesecake with Dried Orange topped with a Cranberry Glaze
Cranberry Cheesecake
Apple Spice Cheesecake
Sweet Potato Cheesecake with Pecans
Chocolate Hazelnut
Cinnamon Chocolate Chipper Cheesecake with Ganache Decoration

A slice of creamy peanut butter pie with chocolate drizzle on a white plate.

Fall Pies

$30-$40

Who doesn't love a great homemade pie? Our pies were the talk of the Town when we visited the City of York this summer! So we're offering them again with a fall twist. All pies are a 9" pie with either a crumb, lattice or full crust top. Please indicate which top when you order. You can choose from:

Apple
Pumpkin
Sweet Potato Pie
Sweet Potato & Beetroot Pie
Southern Pecan Pie
Maple Bourbon Pecan Pie
Apple Streusel Pie
Maple Bourbon Peach Pie
Maple Cream Pie
Sugar Cream Pie
Peanut Butter Dream

Fall inspired Macarons

12/$24

Our Macarons are made fresh (not purchased from US Foods or other commercially made vendors) You can taste the difference in a Fort Mill Bakery Macaron! Our fall macarons are ready and waiting for you to order! Choose from:

Pumpkin spice
Cinnamon chai
Green tea
Apple Spice and bourbon
Bourbon Maple Bacon on a vanilla or chocolate shell
Maca Cinnamon Chai & chocolate
Smores
Spiced Macaron with Apple Pie buttercream filling
Maple Macaron with cinnamon spice filling
Salted Caramel

Fall inspired Brownies

$35

Apple Butter Blondies
Brown Butter Apple Blondies
Pumpkin Spiced Fudge Brownies
Pumpkin Brownie
Pumpkin Cheesecake Brownie (add $5 to price)
Butterscotch Blondie Chip Brownies

Don't forget about our brownies and sweet treats page! More favorites are there.

We will only have pies pre-made ready for pick up at Thanksgiving. All other items listed here require at least a 3 day advance notice.