Fort Mill Bakery's Cheesecake Menu

Enjoy our New York style cheesecake in Fort Mill, SC, made fresh to order with a smooth, creamy texture and a rich homemade graham cracker crust. This classic dessert is perfect for any occasion and delivers a truly melt-in-your-mouth experience.

📅 Pre-order required (5 days notice)
👉 A must-try for cheesecake lovers in Fort Mill!

Indulge in our rich chocolate cheesecake in Fort Mill, SC, made fresh to order with a smooth, creamy texture and deep chocolate flavor on a homemade graham cracker crust. Perfect for any occasion, this decadent dessert is a must for chocolate lovers.

Chocolate cheesecake choices by Fort Mill Bakery

• Chocolate Turtle (pictured)
• Milk or Dark Chocolate
• Mint Chocolate
• Chocolate Raspberry
• Chocolate Strawberry
• Marbled 

📅 Pre-order required (5 days notice)
👉 A top choice for cheesecake lovers in Fort Mill!

At Fort Mill Bakery, our fruit cheesecakes in Fort Mill, SC are made fresh to order with a smooth, creamy filling and a classic homemade graham cracker crust. Flavors include strawberry, raspberry, blueberry, blackberry, and peach—each offering a perfect balance of rich cheesecake and fresh fruit flavor. We've listed our most popular fruit cheesecakes below. Pictured  is our pineapple passion fruit cheesecake by Fort Mill Bakery. 

 Enjoy our fresh strawberry cheesecake in Fort Mill, SC, made with a smooth, creamy base and topped with sweet strawberry flavor over a homemade graham cracker crust. A classic favorite for any occasion.

• Pre-order required -5 days notice
• Can order marbled (as shown) or just with strawberry top. 
• Specify marbled or fruit top on the Fort Mill Bakery Order form

Our key lime cheesecake in Fort Mill, SC blends creamy cheesecake with a bright, tangy citrus flavor on a buttery graham cracker crust. Light, refreshing, and perfect for spring and summer celebrations. 

We can also do a Lemon Merginue Cheesecake, but find the Key Lime to be more popular. 

Indulge in our raspberry cheesecake in Fort Mill, SC, featuring a rich, smooth filling with a vibrant raspberry compote/gel finish and a homemade graham cracker crust. A perfect balance of sweet and tart. When in season we use fresh local raspberries. We also offer this in a Black Raspberry flavor. 

• Pre-order required -5 days notice
• Can order marbled or just with our luscious raspberry top. 
• Specify marbled or fruit top on the Fort Mill Bakery Order form

Looking for something unique? We offer custom cheesecake flavors in Fort Mill, SC tailored to your taste and event. From classic combinations to creative specialty flavors, we’ll create something just for you. Here's some of our popular custom cheesecake flavors: 

• Cranberry Orange (shown)
• Double Pumpkin
• Smores
• Grasshopper (Creme De 
• Oreo
• Pre-order required -5 days notice
• Specify flavor on the Fort Mill Bakery Order form

Indulge yourself to the ultimate cheesecake experience. Our Marbled Cheesecakes fuse rich flavors with visually stunning swirls. They're a cheesecake lover's dream. When completing your online order form, make sure to tell us which marbled cheesecake flavor you're ordering. Choose from the following:

• Mocha 
• Strawberry
• Raspberry (pictured)
• Traditional (plain & chocolate) 
• White Chocolate & Caramel
• 5 day pre order notice