Fort Mill Bakery Pies ~All Fresh Baked Pies

Enjoy our classic apple pie in Fort Mill, SC, filled with tender, spiced apples and baked in our flaky, buttery homemade crust. A timeless favorite perfect for any celebration. Please specify topping when ordering. Choices are:

•  Apple Crumb Top
• Apple Lattice top (shown)
• Apple Full Crust
  📅 Pre-order required -4 day notice

Celebrate Pi Day (March 14-every year) with delicious, made-to-order pies in Fort Mill, SC from Fort Mill Bakery. Our annual Pi Day menu features classic favorites and specialty flavors, all baked fresh with high-quality ingredients and homemade crusts.

Whether you’re searching for Pi Day pies near Fort Mill, apple pie Fort Mill SC, or a local bakery offering fresh pies for Pi Day, we’ve got the perfect dessert for your celebration.

Choose a variety of fresh pies in Fort Mill, SC, from our menu.

Strawberry pie in Fort Mill, SC features sweet, vibrant strawberries inside a flaky, buttery homemade crust. A light and refreshing dessert option. We use local strawberries to support our farms when in season. 

• No Bake Strawberry Pie
• Baked Strawberry Pie
• Strawberry Rhubarb Pie (shown)
• Please specify Pie type when ordering using Fort Mill Bakery Order form

📅 Pre-order required -4 day notice

 Enjoy our homemade peach pie in Fort Mill, SC, filled with sweet, juicy peaches, grown locally when in season & baked in our flaky, buttery homemade crust. A warm, comforting dessert perfect for any occasion.  Please specify topping when ordering. Choices are:

• Peach Bourbon Crumb Top(shown)
• Peach Lattice Top
• Peach Full Crust
  📅 Pre-order required -4 day notice

Try our blueberry pie in Fort Mill, SC, made with deep, juicy blueberry filling and baked in a golden, flaky, buttery homemade crust. Perfectly balanced and full of flavor.

• Blueberry Crumb Top
• Blueberry Lattice Top (shown)
• Blueberry Full Crust

📅 Pre-order required -4 day notice

 Enjoy our homemade cherry pie in Fort Mill, SC, filled with sweet, juicy cherries, grown locally when in season & baked in our flaky, buttery homemade crust. A warm, comforting dessert perfect for any occasion.  Please specify Cherry type & topping when ordering. Choices are:

• Sour Cherry Pie Crumb Top
• Sour Cherry Pie Lattice Top
• Sour Cherry Pie Full Crust
• Traditional Cherry Pie Crumb Top
• Cherry Pie Lattice Top
• Traditional Cherry Pie Full Crust
  📅 Pre-order required -4 day notice

Try our blackberry pie in Fort Mill, SC, made with deep, juicy blackberry filling and baked in a golden, flaky, buttery homemade crust. Perfectly balanced and full of flavor.

• Blackberry Bourbon Crumb Top
• Blackberry Lattice Top(shown)
• Blackberry Full Crust

📅 Pre-order required -4 day notice

 Our classic lemon meringue pie in Fort Mill, SC combines a bright, tangy lemon filling with a fluffy toasted meringue topping, all set in a flaky, buttery homemade crust. Light, refreshing, and perfectly balanced. 

• Pre order ~4 days required
• Order here using the Fort Mill Bakery Order Form

 If you’re searching for homemade tarts near Fort Mill or a trusted bakery in Fort Mill, SC offering fresh desserts, Fort Mill Bakery delivers desserts that are both visually stunning and full of flavor.

👉 Pre-order your cream based or fruit tarts today and enjoy a made-to-order dessert you won’t for! They're that good!

  Enjoy our refreshing key lime pie in Fort Mill, SC, made with a smooth, creamy lime filling and a hint of citrus tang, finished in a buttery homemade crust. A perfect balance of sweet and tart. 

• Pre order ~4 days required
• Order here using the Fort Mill Bakery Order Form

 Indulge in our rich chocolate cream pie in Fort Mill, SC, featuring a smooth, velvety chocolate filling topped with light whipped cream in a flaky, buttery homemade crust. A must-have for chocolate lovers! We offer the following:

• Traditional Chocolate Cream (Shown) 
• Chocolate Silk 
• Chocolate PB (aka~Buckeye)
• Pre order ~4 days required
• Specify flavor when ordering using the Fort Mill Bakery Order Form

 Try our traditional Hoosier pie in Fort Mill, SC, a rich and creamy vanilla custard-style pie baked in a flaky, buttery homemade crust. A simple yet indulgent dessert with classic flavor. 

• Pre order ~4 days required
• Ready to order? Use the Fort Mill Bakery Order Form

  Our Southern-style chess pie in Fort Mill, SC features a smooth, sweet custard filling with a slightly caramelized top, baked in a flaky, buttery homemade crust. A timeless favorite for any occasion. 

• Pre order ~4 days required
• Ready to order?  Use the Fort Mill Bakery Order Form