Our Hoosier pie, also known as sugar cream pie, is Indiana's official state pie. It's a rich custard pie with nutmeg and other spices, and its very similar to a custard pie, but this one is less creamy due to the difference in the recipes. But just as oh, so Good!
A rich molasses "cake" with a molasses wet bottom pie in a buttery flaky crust and then topped with a flavorful crumb topping. This is a traditional "PA German-Dutch" recipe from my great-grandma.
This pie is a Southern Staple at any gathering! It has a deliciously creamy and sweet cream cheese filling in a graham cracker crust with our very own cherry pie filling on top. It melts in your mouth and has you coming back for more! recipe credit from my Grams K.
A pie for even diabetics to love! This pie is huge on flavor and low on sugar due to the use of real whipped cream, which allows the caramel and coffee flavors to rise above all others. Crust is created from nilla wafers.
A Southern Family Favorite created with our buttery crust then filled with our creamy vanilla bean custard, layered with sliced bananas and clouds of real whipped cream. This IS it's what dessert dreams are made of!
A rich coconut custard base blended with sweetened and toasted coconut flakes in a buttery flaky crust and then topped with fresh whipped cream and coconut.
Fresh made key lime curd, whipped cream topping and buttery graham cracker crust
A rich cocoa base blended into this whipped silk dream layered onto a rich & buttery flaky crust and then topped with fresh whipped cream and chocolate flakes. You can't resist this one!
Fresh made lemon curd, meringue topping and flaky pie crust
A silky blend of Peanut butter cream and white Belgian Callebaut Chocolate in a homemade Chocolate Cookie Crust, topped with a drizzle of chocolate and then surrounded in a halo of Real Whipped Cream. (Note: we never use cool whip in any of our pies! Natural heavy cream is always the best!)
Our Custard Pie is the traditional baked custard pie filling and it is not to be confused with a cream custard pie ~they're simply not the same. We do use our blend of spices in the custard itself, not just in the crust! We believe this brings out the flavors intended in this traditional dessert.
*Please read description fully*
A variety of apples used to create this mouth-watering pie with our handmade flaky bottom crust. Choose either a lattice top or Crumb Top when ordering.
This is Just like the one grandma use to make!
Fresh local pumpkins are used to create this smooth and rich crème pie with a flaky bottom crust.
Fall - Winter Seasonal Item
Pecan Pie is a southern classic dessert to which no Thanksgiving is complete! Its also great to solve that "Salty & Sweet" craving. The sweetness of the pecan filling and the slightly salty crust, just hit the spot! Pecan pie is also just as wonderfully rich as an apple pie, yet provides you with that "Southern Comfort" feel.
Always in season pie. We create our Peach Pie Filling using our Favorite Bourbon and Local Peach Growers and then can it ourselves to have this pie available all year! This is a "TDFP - to die for pie!" Our peach pie has a bourbon strudel top and a rich buttery bottom crust and well the peach filling speaks for itself!
Fresh Blueberries or blackberries tucked inside two flaky crusts. Take one home and serve warm with vanilla ice cream or fresh creme. Blueberry Pie Is available year round. Blackberry is available now year round, but limited.
- Specify which berry in your order.
Fresh local Strawberries are used to create this mouth-watering pie with a flaky bottom crust. Choose between a lattice top or crumb topping on pie when ordering. As well as if you prefer the baked or refrigerated version of this pie, as both are possible. Never had a baked strawberry crumb pie? Oh~ you gotta try it!
Fresh local Strawberries and rhubarb are used to create this mouth-watering sweet, tart pie with a flaky bottom crust and Crumb Topping. A refreshing spring & early summer treat best served with a scoop of vanilla ice cream! (we think so anyway)
Early Spring Seasonal Item- only.
We have several local sources to find the Rhubarb, but need at least 7 days notice prior to your pick up date.
Fresh local rhubarb is used to create this delectably sweet-tart fruit pie with a flaky bottom crust and Crumb Topping.
Please order early on this spring Fav!
We have several localsources to find the Rhubarb, but need at least 7 days notice prior to your pick up date.
Early Spring Seasonal Item- only.
Note: We will be creating a Strawberry Rhubarb filling of our own this spring (2024) So we can offer this pie during the summer months. We'll let you know, but don't be afraid to ask about it!
Our mission is to provide you w/high quality, freshly made custom products. We're aware some cottage/home bakers undersell us. Pies according to SC State Health Dept aren't part of the Cottage laws, so you get what you pay for!
We pride ourselves on the quality, not quantity of products, on our reviews from clients & our product reputation - its that simple!
If you failed to plan ahead, we're sorry but we cannot rush any pie order All pies must be ordered 5 days in advance of your expected date.
Our mission is to provide you w/high quality, freshly made custom products. We want to display this in all our images, so having a degree in art and photography, the owner used this to create the pie images you see. Yes some staging ideas were borrowed from images on the net, but if "ain't broke, why fix it and we still made the pies" so there ain't nothing wrong with saving a little time on ourselves to show you our best!
~ ALL ORDERS CONFIRMED BY EMAIL ~ ORDERING ~ USE ONLINE ORDER TAB AT TOP OF PAGE ~Prices do not include SC tax rate
Copyright © 2024 Fort Mill Bakery - All Rights Reserved.
Powered by GoDaddy
We're excited to be a new vendor this year during The City of York Summer Concert Series
We will have several events this summer, but May 30th is our first one! Couldn't be more pleased! Come enjoy some great local musical talent and vendors! If you would like to order an item for pick up at the event, place your order using our online order form - fortmillbakery.com/order-online
If you simply wish to visit our tent, we'll have items that are themed to this event & a flashback to
some old favorite summer sweets!
Event details: May 30th 7PM-10PM
Location: 55 North Congress Street, York SC