Fresh Baked Pies & Tarts in Fort Mill

Celebrate Pi Day (March 14-every year) with delicious, made-to-order pies in Fort Mill, SC from Fort Mill Bakery. Our annual Pi Day menu features classic favorites and specialty flavors, all baked fresh with high-quality ingredients and homemade crusts.

Whether you’re searching for Pi Day pies near Fort Mill, apple pie Fort Mill SC, or a local bakery offering fresh pies for Pi Day, we’ve got the perfect dessert for your celebration.

Choose a variety of fresh pies in Fort Mill, SC, from our menu.

Most locals aren’t originally from SC, and I embrace my PA Dutch roots by offering this Wet‑Bottom Shoo‑Fly Pie. Made to order in the traditional style my mom and grandma taught me. Some call it “molasses pie” or “Schuuflee‑Pai” in PA Dutch. If you’ve never, ever had it, you don’t know what you’re missing! 

It’s one of my favorites—especially with morning coffee in the fall. 

📅 Pre‑order required: 4‑day notice 

Enjoy our classic apple pie in Fort Mill, SC, filled with tender, spiced apples and baked in our flaky, buttery homemade crust. A timeless favorite perfect for any celebration. Please specify crust topping when ordering. Choices are:

•  Apple Crumb Top
• Apple Lattice top 
• Apple Full Crust (shown)
  📅 4 day Pre-order required for all non-holiday orders. Holiday orders must be in by deadline. 

Strawberry pie in Fort Mill, SC features sweet, vibrant strawberries inside a flaky, buttery homemade crust. A light and refreshing dessert option. We use local strawberries to support our farms when in season. 

• No Bake Strawberry Pie
• Baked Strawberry Pie
• Strawberry Rhubarb Pie (shown)
• Please specify Pie type when ordering using Fort Mill Bakery Order form

📅 Pre-order required -4 day notice

 Enjoy our homemade peach pie in Fort Mill, SC, filled with sweet, juicy peaches, grown locally when in season & baked in our flaky, buttery homemade crust. A warm, comforting dessert perfect for any occasion.  Please specify topping when ordering. Choices are:

• Peach Bourbon Crumb Top(shown)
• Peach Lattice Top
• Peach Full Crust
  📅  4 day Pre-order required for all non-holiday orders. Holiday orders must be in by deadline. 

Try our blueberry pie in Fort Mill, SC, made with deep, juicy blueberry filling and baked in a golden, flaky, buttery homemade crust. Perfectly balanced and full of flavor.

• Blueberry Crumb Top
• Blueberry Lattice Top (shown)
• Blueberry Full Crust

📅  4 day Pre-order required for all non-holiday orders. Holiday orders must be in by deadline. 

 Enjoy our homemade cherry pie in Fort Mill, SC, filled with sweet, juicy cherries, grown locally when in season & baked in our flaky, buttery homemade crust. A warm, comforting dessert perfect for any occasion.  Please specify Cherry type & topping when ordering. Choices are:

• Sour Cherry Pie Crumb, Lattice or Full  Crust top
• Traditional Cherry Pie Crumb  or Lattice Top
• Traditional Cherry Pie Full Crust
• 
  📅  4 day Pre-order required for all non-holiday orders. Holiday orders must be in by deadline. 

Try our blackberry pie in Fort Mill, SC, made with deep, juicy blackberry filling and baked in a golden, flaky, buttery homemade crust. Perfectly balanced and full of flavor.

• Blackberry Bourbon Crumb Top
• Blackberry Lattice Top(shown)
• Blackberry Full Crust

📅  4 day Pre-order required for all non-holiday orders. Holiday orders must be in by deadline. 

At Fort Mill Bakery, our pumpkin pie is a smooth, velvety custard baked in a buttery homemade crust with just the right touch of fall spices. It’s cozy, comforting, and perfectly paired with Thanksgiving and other holiday feasts as a warm, nostalgic finish. 

📅  4 day Pre-order required for all non-holiday orders. Holiday orders must be in by deadline. 

Try our blackberry pie in Fort Mill, SC, made with deep, juicy blackberry filling and baked in a golden, flaky, buttery homemade crust. Perfectly balanced and full of flavor.

• Blackberry Bourbon Crumb Top
• Blackberry Lattice Top(shown)
• Blackberry Full Crust

📅  4 day Pre-order required for all non-holiday orders. Holiday orders must be in by deadline. 

Enjoy our refreshing key lime pie in Fort Mill, SC, made with a smooth, creamy lime filling and a hint of citrus tang, finished in a buttery homemade crust. A perfect balance of sweet and tart. 

📅  4 day Pre-order required for all non-holiday orders. Holiday orders must be in by deadline. 

Indulge in our rich chocolate cream pie in Fort Mill, SC, featuring a smooth, velvety chocolate filling topped with light whipped cream in a flaky, buttery homemade crust. A must-have for chocolate lovers! We offer the following:

• Traditional Chocolate Cream (Shown) 
• Chocolate Silk 
• Chocolate PB (aka~OH Buckeye Pie)

📅 4 day Pre-order required for all non-holiday orders. Holiday orders must be in by deadline. 

 If you’re searching for homemade tarts near Fort Mill or a trusted bakery in Fort Mill, SC offering fresh desserts, Fort Mill Bakery delivers desserts that are both visually stunning and full of flavor.

👉 Pre-order your cream based or fruit tarts today and enjoy a made-to-order dessert you won’t for! They're that good!

We require a 4‑day pre‑order for all pies & tarts. 

We bake in a shared commercial kitchen; every session must be scheduled — unlike a cottage kitchen where orders can start anytime. 

Pies & tarts also can’t be made in a cottage kitchen; they’re Temperature‑Control‑for‑Safety items regulated by the SC Dept. Of Ag. & must be produced in a licensed commercial space. 

This is part of why our pies and tarts cost more: they’re made properly, & in small batches — never mass‑produced & no preservatives. 

 Enjoy our refreshing Fresh Citron Tart (lemon tart- pictured) in Fort Mill, SC, made with a smooth, creamy lemon curd filling, made from scratch and then finished in a buttery sable crust. A perfect balance of sweet and tart. 

Other fruit based tarts we offer: 

• Strawberry
• Raspberry
• Raspberry Lemon
• Blackberry 
• Fresh Fruit topped tart - lemon base

📅 Pre-order required -4 day notice

Indulge in our rich cream-based tarst in Fort Mill, SC. Pictured is our Chocolate tart finished with sea salt in a chocolate‑graham crust. A must‑have for chocolate lovers!

Fort Mill Bakery’s cream‑based tarts:   

• Traditional Chocolate (Shown) 
• Vanilla Bean
• Chocolate Peanut Butter Layered**
• Tiramisu Cream
• Berry‑Inspired Cream Tarts*

📅 Pre‑order required — 4‑day notice   

*Specify flavor for Berry‑Inspired Tarts.

 **PB can be substituted with almond or cashew butter for customers with peanut allergy

 Try our traditional Hoosier pie in Fort Mill, SC, a rich and creamy vanilla custard-style pie baked in a flaky, buttery homemade crust. A simple yet indulgent dessert with classic flavor. 

• Pre order ~4 days required